Feb. 26th, 2010 07:22 am
Stupid Legislature Tricks
So. The California Legislature voted
to approve a No Cussing Week starting Monday.
I plan to cuss at least four times a day in protest of this kind of silly
nonsense.
I mean, really. The whole mess was started by this 16 year old kid, who
says, among other things, "People use cussing so frequently that they don't
even know it, but it really offends a lot of people."
Actually, kid, I know exactly when I cuss. So do most folks. And perhaps
the people who are so offended by it should recognize that it's not a knife
in their gut, or a penis in their face, but a word. And this
attitude that a word is offensive in and of itself is offensive to me as
both a teacher of English and a linguist.
This is even true of racial and sexual pejoratives. There is nothing
inherently offensive about the word "Faggot," for example. It's just
letters and sounds. What is offensive isn't the word, it's the
attitudes and beliefs behind the word. Context is everything. If I
call my ex-boyfriend a fag, he thinks it's funny. It's an old joke between
us, and the humor of me, who has been there, using it, makes him
laugh. If, however, some random asshole sees him in public, yells "Fag!" at
him, and moves on, that's offensive, because the context is totally
different. That person truly believes him to be less than a person.
Similarly, there are various contexts in which calling my wife "bitch" can
be anywhere from funny to grounds for my sleeping in the spare room.
Teenagers know this instinctively. Many black students will call each other
N----- (I censor it for lots of reasons: My Journal, My Rules). Now, to me,
that word has seriously bad connotations no matter what. My sister is black,
my aunt is black, I have been raised to consider that word a no-fly zone.
Consequently, I don't like it used in my classroom, partly because of my
own emotional response and also because while some students are ok with it,
not all are, and I have to be sensitive to that. But those same students
who use the word regularly with each other will not tolerate it from someone
who is using it abusively--and they can tell.
Anyway, the point of my rambling is really that this is a very stupid thing
for the state legislature to be doing. Feel free to debate in the comments,
but please understand I won't be able to reply to you until I get home this
evening. I can post from work via email, but I can't comment from work
(stupid district filters) and I didn't bring my smartphone (Probably it's
smarter than I am today).
to approve a No Cussing Week starting Monday.
I plan to cuss at least four times a day in protest of this kind of silly
nonsense.
I mean, really. The whole mess was started by this 16 year old kid, who
says, among other things, "People use cussing so frequently that they don't
even know it, but it really offends a lot of people."
Actually, kid, I know exactly when I cuss. So do most folks. And perhaps
the people who are so offended by it should recognize that it's not a knife
in their gut, or a penis in their face, but a word. And this
attitude that a word is offensive in and of itself is offensive to me as
both a teacher of English and a linguist.
This is even true of racial and sexual pejoratives. There is nothing
inherently offensive about the word "Faggot," for example. It's just
letters and sounds. What is offensive isn't the word, it's the
attitudes and beliefs behind the word. Context is everything. If I
call my ex-boyfriend a fag, he thinks it's funny. It's an old joke between
us, and the humor of me, who has been there, using it, makes him
laugh. If, however, some random asshole sees him in public, yells "Fag!" at
him, and moves on, that's offensive, because the context is totally
different. That person truly believes him to be less than a person.
Similarly, there are various contexts in which calling my wife "bitch" can
be anywhere from funny to grounds for my sleeping in the spare room.
Teenagers know this instinctively. Many black students will call each other
N----- (I censor it for lots of reasons: My Journal, My Rules). Now, to me,
that word has seriously bad connotations no matter what. My sister is black,
my aunt is black, I have been raised to consider that word a no-fly zone.
Consequently, I don't like it used in my classroom, partly because of my
own emotional response and also because while some students are ok with it,
not all are, and I have to be sensitive to that. But those same students
who use the word regularly with each other will not tolerate it from someone
who is using it abusively--and they can tell.
Anyway, the point of my rambling is really that this is a very stupid thing
for the state legislature to be doing. Feel free to debate in the comments,
but please understand I won't be able to reply to you until I get home this
evening. I can post from work via email, but I can't comment from work
(stupid district filters) and I didn't bring my smartphone (Probably it's
smarter than I am today).