Disclaimer: Michael is an admitted Elitist RPG snobLately a disturbing trend has begun, one which is getting me closer and closer to walking into my local RPG store with an AK-47 and a list of names. That soul-killing phenomenon is the ever-widening accepted definition of "RPG."
Lately when I go to RPG stores, or get into online discussions on RPGs, someone starts yapping about "Magic: The Gathering" or one of the ten billion other card games out now. Or they claim to be RPGers, then start blithering about Warhammer. Or Final Fantasy.
For the record: An RPG is a roleplaying game played either at the tabletop with other live humans, dice, and paper, or on a MUSH/MUCK (not MUDs, which are usually home to 14 year-olds who want to kill things electronically).
Update: LARPs are also RPGsA RPG is NOT a card game, a PC game, or a PS2/GameCube/XBox game.
PC Games that are based on the RPG concept -- leveling, learning skills, and above all a decent plot -- are PCRPGs. Card games are just that. Warhammer is a nice game, but not roleplaying, no matter how many times you grunt as your Orc army decimates the Elven Nation.
Now, don't get me wrong; I'm as addicted to Final Fantasy's various incarnations (ok, only Eight and Ten) as the next guy. And yes,
shawndo, Deus Ex is the most awesome PC game of that genre EVER. And I can't wait for Deus Ex 2. But it's not a RPG.
End Elitist partly tongue-in-cheek Rant.